Category: Social Networking

Back to CraigRitchie.com Home

on Transparency

on Transparency

Consumers started the fire. Organizations need to stop trying to fight it.

billyjoel1

The buzz words are changing. As the term “Web 2.0” becomes antiquated, and the masses embrace social media, brands, corporations and organizations are starting to understand the implications of the new paradigms of the web.

Transparency is what’s driving consumer decision now, and the trust that is formed through the authentic collective voice of a brand’s management team, employees and customers.

At this point, I’m starting to feel dirty just saying the words “messaging” and “tone” when discussing “campaigns.”

In Boy Scouts, young campers are taught to start a one-match fire – focusing one’s skill on building the framework of the fuel so that it catches with only one match. I’ll do better than that. I’ll give you six matches to start the transparency fire in your organization.

Here are six catalysts to spark your new focus on authenticity and transparency.

Authencity drives consumer choices…

1. Joseph Pine defines the new Experience economy in this TED talk from 2004, and how “Authenticity is becoming the new consumer sensibility.”

… and they trust only human voices…

cluetrain2. The Cluetrain Manifesto celebrated its 10-year anniversary with a new edition published this year. It describes how consumers are finding trust and truth through human voices within your organization, or elsewhere – that is, however they wish. From the book: “The corporation pretends to speak, but its voice is that of a third-rate actor in a fourth-rate play, uttering lines no one believes in a manner no one respects.”

… and some of these voices are much “louder” than others…

trustagents3. Chris Brogan and Julien Smith’s Trust Agents just hit the New York Times Bestseller list. It’s a how-to guide, defining and training the individuals in your organization best practices to be honest as they build genuine relationships. From the cover flap: “Trust Agents wield enough online influence to build up and bring down a business’ reputation.”

… so organizations must find a new way to communicate…

tacticaltransparency4. Shel Holtz and John C. Havens’ Tactical Transparency presents a framework for dealing with all the scary situations that big brands fear as they dip their toes in to Social Media. From the book: “Tactical Transparency provides dozens of case studies and interviews that address the implementation of transparency tools at the highest levels of the organization and the lowest. Transparency succeeds when it is embedded into the culture of a company, not implemented as a program designed to be exercised by only a few.”

… and it must go all the way to the top…

mscarficeos

5. Organic’s CFO and COO Marita Scarfi explains the opportunity CEOs are missing if they don’t participate in Social Media and open conversations, in this recent Threeminds blog post. “Being engaged with your customers allows you to produce better products/services which, in turn, leads to improved customer loyalty. Ultimately this helps increase sales and fosters stronger company financial performance (e.g. increased shareholder value).”

… just like these numerous examples of management-level-driven open conversations.

ceoblogslist

6. The NewPR Wiki lists dozens of blogs written by Management-level contributors, where issues are being discussed, and trust is growing in brands… and the people that are behind them.

One last tip, campers: Campfires start quicker when the team works together, and when the structure of the tinder allows in oxygen… Keep it open.

The Hypercube: Buzz, Content and Brand Community Building

hypercube
Phil “PhotoPhilCro” Crozier’s Final Canvas

50 new Nissan Cubes are driving off Canadian cubes dealer lots this month. Each one’s being driven by a brand advocate you only wish you had hired to tout your brand.

The new cars are the reward for months of creation and promotion by these musicians, DJs, dancers, programmers, designers, bloggers, podcasters, poets, writers and artists, and all kinds of creative thinkers; the cream of the crop of 500 competing “auditions” broadcast online over the last three months via social channels. Nissan openly called The Hypercube a social media marketing experiment, choosing to invest only in this channel, and is now pleased to announce (or tweet, perhaps) the successful proof of their thesis.

Nissan Canada’s creative agency, Capital C, went beyond the boilerplate hey-make-us-a-video and please-retweet-our-propaganda “campaigns” that are all too common these days, by offering prizes on which creative minds could really envision spending time and effort.

The Contest

Of 7000 applicants, 500 elite were given Hypercube canvases to audition for the mass public, stumping for daily votes with photos and animation, video, poetry and song. Competitors even took their campaigning offline, including Telma “TSwizz” Costa, who created and distributed pins to drive traffic, and Sean “Cube Man” Williams who literally drove offline traffic in his homemade cardboard Cube costume.

The cream rose quickly, as canvasses brought out the best from these competitors. And believe me, if you followed or friended any of them, you were hearing about it.

Over the course of the contest, so much exceptional content was created, it’s difficult to “highlight” the best stuff. Here are pieces of just three of the intense and daily updated canvasses:

hypercube1
Tony “Tony Holiday” Elston’s final canvas

hypercube2
Brittany Jade “Gunandagirl” Hanson’s final canvas

hypercube3
Delphine “Delf Berg” Bergeron’s final canvas

You can view all of the winning canvasses at thehypercube.ca

The Platforms

The Hypercube site was just the town hall of this experience, though, as competitors created videos on YouTube…

Posted images to Flickr…

hypercubeflickr

Tweeted (like crazy)…

hypercubetwitter

built web pages and blogs, and invoked social graphs from their other communities. For example, contestant Andre Molnar looked to leverage the passionate Drupal community, by promising to create the “Drupliconcube,” a Nissan cube “decked out in Druplicons, spreading the Drupal love to the streets.

hypercubedrupal

Deeper Interactions

More than just pleas for votes, these daily updates became meaningful interactions between the competitors. Williams sent out a YouTube dance-off challenge to his fellow participants, and created this mashup:

Some social media users voiced disapproval of the campaign, including Shawn Micallef, who questioned the quality of the engagement suggests a line had been crossed, from daily updates from friends and outright spam. I disagree, as social media users are constantly pushing out posts and tweets that may annoy some, but be useful to others. This is the very nature of Social Currency, and one can, in fact, “Unfollow.” Furthermore, this type of repetition occurs with non-marketing events even more than with campaigns. When Michael Jackson died, or during the Obama campaign, the tidal wave of repetitious posts seemed to drown most other conversation. The Hypercube campaign wasn’t perfect, but neither is Facebook, nor Twitter, themselves.

The Finale

Such a momentous story had to end with an explosive climax, and on June 24, it did just that. Contestants gathered with friends at events simulcast in Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver. (Small-town contestants got together on their own in other provinces, too.) Contestants performed live between DJ sets, mingled over drinks, and sat in the highly-coveted Cubes on display. Winners were announced across the country via big screen video and some tight computer graphics. The dance floor of CiRCA in Toronto was like a minefield as groups of friends exploded in cheers when the local winners were listed off. It seemed like an endless supply of car keys were handed out, and many of the winners were ironically rendered speechless.

One can’t argue the level of quality and vastly disparate creative skillsets with which the Cube brand has been aligned.

The Outcome

Now, Nissan Canada has tons of authentic content to work with, generated by skilled creatives at a low cost. The winners are required to update their canvasses twice a month for the next year, but the brand will get a lot more than that, I predict, as these content generators are eager to share their experiences on the road. And they’ve also got promises to keep with their fans. Singer/Cube-winner Curtis Santiago promised to drive to a voter’s house in his cube, anywhere in Canada, to play a house party. No doubt he’ll be blogging and vlogging the whole trip.

I’ll admit, at first glance, I assumed Nissan Canada and Capital C’s campaign was a huge gamble. All too often, big brands create deep connections with new communities, but then drop these connections as soon as their campaign is over. Nissan has demonstrated how to think and plan long term; find–no, create passionate advocates who themselves created a plethora of content and awareness; and build a brand in partnership with their customers.

The Community

Moreover, this campaign was just the spark, a great success already, but the story of the Nissan Cube and the CubeCommunity is just beginning. Cubecommunity.ca teases us with a “coming soon” page, but the long-term strategy is obvious, as the community has all of the core requirements, starting with deeply invested and passionate community leaders. I look forward to following this community, and, in many ways, the hard work for Nissan and Capital C has just begun.

I’m happy to admit, the bar’s just been raised for “social media marketing.”

Meeting virtually in real life (Part 1): Web strategy and tools are changing the conversation at conferences

meshaudience1.jpgWeb conferences have become host to the new wave of viral tools and technologies that are enhancing community and business meetings. Carlson Marketing calls this next-gen conference style ‘Meetings 2.0.’ As a worldwide enabler of business meetings, Carlson has added mobile tools and social networking to their meetings and events offerings, which expands the experience from just ‘During’ to include ‘Before’ and ‘After.’

Twead carefully during your keynote

mesh-logo.gifRecently, at the Toronto Mesh web conference, a lot was revealed about the future of conferences. Specifically, the massive impact of mobile devices and social media tools on these types of get-togethers. The communication vehicle of choice? Twitter, of course. During the two-day event, power-tweeters (frequent users of Twitter) introduced the power and benefits of micro-blogging to dozens of twuddites. (Twitter luddites)

What was the call to action for these new adopters? Easily a quarter of the audience members in any given session had laptops open, and half of them were twittering amongst themselves, expanding the presentations and panels to deep discussions in the seats.

twemes.gifTwemes, a Twitter API implemetation, further enabled the conversation between tweeters, as Mesh attendees or ‘Meshies’ tagged their 140-character-or-less comments with ‘#mesh08,’ allowing the community to follow the discussion in real time as the comments rolled by. You can see all of these comments aggregated here.

I recommend trying out Twemes.com: ideally, follow a “hot pick” in the top right corner (these are usually conferences) and click “start live update” to see the topic-tagged twitters roll by. You can imagine the additional engagement this provides for events and conferences.

The added value of the Twitter conversation backchannel was obvious. During the conference, Meshies were using Twitter to discuss the future of music as a business model, and taking the liberty of re-branding Saturn’s awkwardly named social network ImSaturn (the marketer from Saturn tried desperately to point us to the correct URL, but stumbled through the difficult address).

Do we even have to attend anymore?

scribblelive.gifScribbleLive was unveiled at Mesh ‘08, a live blogging platform with real-time updates. In this forum, ScribbleLive users live-blogged forums and presentations, allowing multi-taskers and attendees in other sessions follow multiple discussions. For a great example of the group blogging output, check out the live blog of Steve Jobs’ Keynote at the WWDC, including his announcement of the new iPhone 3G.

iphone.jpg

My mobile meeting manager

Mesh ‘08 also boasted an impressive, although slightly off-the-mark blackberry app. The technically-oriented (crackberry-addicted) audience presented an optimal opportunity for Sweet Caesar to offer a free downloadable guide to the event. The features and user experience of the app were quite valuable, even though it just left me wanting more.

Among the features were a venue map, schedule and presenter bios. Unfortunately, this information didn’t update over the two days and was incorrect (as conference schedules go) as soon as the first keynote began. Overall however, the implementation demonstrated the potential for great value in the future. Now event planners must consider “What is my mobile strategy?” “What is my web strategy?” Maybe next time we’ll see the integration of Twitter, ScribbleLive and social networking tools to enhance our next Mesh (or your next conference’s) experience.

Look for Part 2 of my post on the evolution of Meetings and Conferences: Meeting virtually in real life (Part 2): Entertain us, we’re bored and twittering.

Along with everything else, I think Facebook might be the new Louvre (This is Facebook marketing done right)

dellgraffiti.jpgWhile Seth Godin is questioning the longevity of everyone’s patience for “Green” marketing, Dell has achieved great success in its current campaign, “What does ‘green’ mean to you?” In partnership with and in support of Regeneration.org, Facebookers can use the Graffiti tool to enter their artwork to be voted on by their fellow social networkers.

More than 7,000 entries have been submitted.

The top 150 (yes, One Hundred and Fifty, not top 10 or 20…) are now available for voting, and the quality of art is astonishing. Spend some time in the virtual art show here.

Also notable is the quality of the conversation and virulence of the campaign. The discussion board boasts more than 100 topics, with conversation ranging from Global Warming – Real, or Hoax?” to sub-campaigns started by the participants suggesting that competitors “Rate the Person Above You’s Grafitti!!”

The engagement reaches beyond the page as 1,471 Facebook fans are spreading word of the campaign.

Quite simply put, there is a monumental difference between social media strategies that sputter and die because of lack of knowledge and direction, and successful campaigns like this one that is lead by expertise and focus.

Hat tip to Jeremiah Owyang (twitter @jowyang) once again for the link.

The 2008 social fallout

I don’t know if you’re experiencing it too, but if 2007 saw a social explosion online, the first quarter of 2008 is witness to the fallout. As Facebook adoption slows, Twitter is exploding with new users, LinkedIn’s engagement seems to be soaring, and niche social media sites are finding their stride among an empowered prosumer population. I’ve spent the last few months using a multitude of tools, and finding new life outside of Facebook.

The fallout is everywhere, and new, real growth from that fallout is happening thanks to users spanning beyond the early adopters and tech-savvy teens. So, ‘Hi’ to the grandmothers and other “late adopters” (CEOs?) out there joining the conversation. It’s richer now, and we’re all benefiting.

The Benefits and Future of Social Media and Web 2.0

Yes, Facebook and Flickr are neat. Tags are cool, and the Long Tail is very intriguing… But where’s this all headed? Microsoft’s latest acquisition, “Photosynth” answers, as demonstrated here.

Web 2.0 Awards 2007

SEOMoz.org has awarded it’s 2007 Web 2.0 Awards. I’m sure these won’t be annual, as the term 2.0 will soon be obsolete, and the majority of the award winners will probably get picked up by the big sharks in the Internet pool.

Social networking for corporations (aka dummies)

communitiesbook.jpgJust like a decade ago, corporations are jumping on the Internet – but this time instead of the blanket, uninformed statement “We need a website,” the suits are shouting the trendy war-cry “We need social networking!”

The benefits, when executed correctly, are obvious. Connecting with one’s customers and market in and allowing them to connect with each other at such a deep level is a modern marketer’s ultimate goal, but crowbarring a Facebook clone and blogs into your website probably isn’t the best method.

To anchor and focus the Web 2.0 strategy and planning for any client or web offering, I consistently turn back to Amy Jo Kim’s self-categorized “cult classic” Community Building on the Web: Secret Strategies for Successful Online Communities. It’s a book from 2000, but the concepts remain relevant in the new age of WOW and Wiki, Flickr and Facebook.

Kim outlines the practices she uses to this day for attracting customers and surfers and increasing stickiness to an addictive level. These practices are commonplace today among the best producers of online-ready games and community web sites, but others, including the corporations and organizations who see the potential of 2.0, don’t have the understanding that is truly necessary to drive users to join, build and return with friends in tow. Community Building on the Web pulls many of its concepts from successful offline communities. Ideally, users must feel that they are a part of something, and that their interaction with the site and with other members truly affects the content, direction and focus.

Amazon reviewer Donald Mitchell describes the design strategies Kim espouses, which I expand on here:

1. Define and articulate your PURPOSE

– As quickly as possible, the user must understand, what is the community for; who are the players involved; what are the benefits of joining and participating?

2. Build flexible, extensible gathering PLACES

– The current trend for Web 2.0 sites is to have a “forum” on every page where there is content. Blog-style comments allow users to interact on every page of the site. Where and how can your users interact?

3. Create meaningful and evolving member PROFILES

– Personalization is more than just putting the user’s name at the top of the page and saying “Welcome back.” Just like in offline communities, users need to feel that their personality and profile affects the way the site works for them and how others interact with them. How can you further define your users, thereby further defining your site?

4. Design for a range of ROLES

– As users join and embrace your community, how will you welcome and instruct newcomers; empower and honor your leaders?

5. Develop a strong LEADERSHIP program

– What better way to create stickiness and simplify maintenance than to allow passionate users to create content, police other members while lowering your costs?

6. Encourage appropriate ETIQUETTE

– Arguably the most difficult to implement, appropriate etiquette is more important than one might think. Web 2.0 sites struggle with it now in many different ways, with chain letters, cyber-bullying, copyright infringement and spamming filling up YouTube’s content and commentary. If the users create the content of your site, how does your site’s voice “sound?”

7. Promoting cyclic EVENTS

– How do your groups “meet,” how can you promote performances and competition?

8. Integrate the RITUALS of community life

– Kim uses an older example from the Ultima MMORPG, where advancing levels or rank, much like in school or at a job, becomes much more important if the transition involves an award ceremony, or going out for drinks. How can you create rituals to entice and reward users?

9. Facilitate member-run SUBGROUPS

– Subgroups are the cornerstone Facebook and World of Warcraft. It is simple enough to say, “We’ll allow users to create and join groups or to link up with friends.” The challenge is to match your Subgroup strategies with your site’s purpose. Who can create subgroups and who can join them? What is the process? What are the benefits? How do others know that a user is a part of these groups?

The book also proposes 3 design principles:

1. Design for growth and change

2. Create and maintain feedback loops

3. Empower your members over time

Amy Jo Kim’s “handbook for community builders” should be read by anyone who wants to build a social network.

She currently operates ShuffleBrain and teaches game design at USC.

You can also check out her Musings of a social architect here.

I’ll be first in line if she decides to write a new version of Community Building on the Web.